August 4th, 2008
LBD Style Off: Alex Gerrard v Cheryl Cole
images courtesy of Splash News/KEYSTONE Press
Which LBD look do you prefer, Kickettes?
Alex Gerrard, she of good legs, large bag, heading for a shop/stroll in black mini-daywear;
or
Cheryl Cole, sans wedding ring, with high-volume hair doing black spangle PM-wear?
alex for me, is she losses the on-the-go-wardrobe (luggage)
I luv Alex’s bag and her shades. I luv Cheryl’s dress and shoes. But overall Cheryl wins my vote. I do fink the pics are a bit unfair tho. They both lk very pretty!
Alex looks pale compared to Cheryls beaming beauty. Or is it just the daylight?
Alexander is carrying a tent! And Cheryl is too bony, but her face is so amazing.
Alexander is carrying a tent! And Cheryl is too bony, but her face is so amazing.
I’m gonna say Alex I actually like the bag I think the how outfit is really nice!!
Cheryl on the strength of her hair and her bag. I hate Alex’s bag, love the dress and sandals but hate the bags. Cheryl’s outfit is perfect
Cheryl on the strength of her hair and her bag. I hate Alex's bag, love the dress and sandals but hate the bags. Cheryl's outfit is perfect
I'm just so happy to see Alex with flat shoes and no bouffant that I had to stop there! She's looking like a nice, pretty, normal girl. Ditch the obese bag and you'll be all set, Mrs. G!
Im too much in love with Cheryls bag to compare Alex's outfit favourably with it!!!
Nghhhhh Alex hands down.
I like Cheryl’s face better than Alex’s, but Alex’s dress is cute. I hate the very big bag she is carrying.
Cheryl has such a pretty face but I really love Alex’s dress. Even though the bag is huge, I think Alex looks quite cute in her picture.
I love alex’s dress
Great legs
And every woman needs a big bag
I HATE Cheryl’s hair
Go Alex
What is that face on the top corner of Cheryl’s picture? Yeesh! Scary.
I think I’m going to go with Cheryl, though…Were it not for the suitcase—I mean, handbag—hanging off Alex’s arm, I’d like her. But I think she should also retire those sandals soon…she’s been wearing them everywhere. The bag just doesn’t match with the dress. It would look much better with a pair of skinny jeans and heels, but that’s just my take.
I like Cheryl’s hair quite a bit, she looks very pretty and happy. The dress is cute, the shoes are too. The pedicure is a bit iffy. But nonetheless.
Honestly, both of these women look very good and they know how to work their dresses so props to them both.
I’m not really a fan of Alex Gerrard, and no, I’m not jealous or anything. Even though she has a fabulous husband. Hahaha. But I really like Cheryl Cole although I just cannot understand her taste in men.
Oh…did you want to know what I thought of their outfits? Cheryl Cole wins by a style mile.
Cheryl’s look is better.
She has better legs, she has the better body and she has the better LBD.
I’m also really beginning to despair about the size of Alex’s bags, which are now the size of a shopping trolley.
Love Alex’s dress! Damn, she does have good legs
Ok both look gorge..but its hard 2 compare since alex is more casual and cheryl dressy! but im gna hav 2 go with alex simply because she looks natural and hasn’t tried too hard yet still looks fab..Love cheryl so dare i say it but compared 2 alex in these pics she looks like shes trying too hard 2 look good!!(too much fake tan compared 2 alex)
I just think that Cheryl looks less WAG like… She seems to look great effortlessly whereas Alex just annoys me with her over-sized handbags and the fact she looks like all she cares about is the way she looks. She does have great legs though! =)
x
I think if you’d have asked me a year or so ago, I’d have said Cheryl, but she’s just too damn thin now. Every time I see pictures of her she looks like a lolly pop. She just looks fragile, which means her clothes don’t seem to hang very well anymore. Alex does boho chic very well, but I do think the bags are getting silly. Do you reckon she’s got Lexie and Lilly-Ella in there?!
God, both look very but very good, but Alex has something that Cheryl doesnt, she looks more fashionista, i think"/ I think that Alex looks better:P
Chezza all the way here although this is one of Alex's best looks. But Cheryl's absolutely gorgeous….
Cheryl wins hands down. She's absolutely gorgeous, at any rate her hair beats Mrs. Gerrard's!
Cheryl looks beautiful, but I'm going to go with Alex. I find myself rooting for her– I really want her to look as beautiful as I know she can. And here she looks lovely.
I love them both!! I think they both look really nice but i have to say that i think Cheryls is better. Sorry alex!
Cheryl's. I'm not a fan of bags so huge you could camp out in them.
I love big bags but Alex's is too much. but her dress is gorgeous and so are her sandals. but I think Cherlyn wins it. the little black dress and clutch combination is lovely.
Cheryl is actually a beautiful woman, whereas Alex just isn't. I don't see the "great legs" everyone is talking about, they are one pasta dish away from being tree trunks complete with cankles. Her dress is cute but you would think those implants would be further up, they are close to waist level here! I vote Cheryl of course, especially sans ring.
It's difficult to compare the two seeing that Alex's outfit is SOOO casual and Cheryl's is more evening wear. I like both for their style. Alex's huge Miu Miu bag and sandals are fab while Cheryl's seguined black dress combined with red clutch is gorgeous. I can't chose.
Can you even see Alex's outfit behind that monstrosity of a bag??? Cheryl wins this one mainly due to her amazing shoes and clutch, I love them both. Side Notes: Man on Cheryls right, gets some moisturiser for those hands. And man behind Cheryl – WTF?????!!!!!!
Hahaha, MXA you're so right! That man with the camera is cracking me up. Fashion-wise, I love Cheryl's getup and Alex's is just okay for me.
I don't really like Alex's dress. It looks good on her, so I don't mind it here, but I'm not a fan of that style in general. Dresses like that make me look like a shapeless stick. I would have added a belt.
Alex gets it just because that is one amazing bag and I love the dress. Cheryl looks ABSOLUTELY amazing, though. It was a hard choice.
I think Cheryl looks pretty amazing. I just don’t find Alex that pretty, I mean she is a pretty girl but she’s nothing extraordinary.
Alex.Deffo. Like The Cheryl dress but prefer the Alex Look. x
Alex is Cute but her dress doesn’t suit her! But Cheryl Looks good and her dress is suitable for her.
Can you even see Alex’s outfit behind that monstrosity of a bag??? Cheryl wins this one mainly due to her amazing shoes and clutch, I love them both. Side Notes: Man on Cheryls right, gets some moisturiser for those hands. And man behind Cheryl – WTF?????!!!!!!
I love everything that Alex is wearing! I don’t think I’ve ever said that before. It feels weird! Cheryl, of course, looks gorgeous.
Alexander looks like she’s off to stomp on some sales assistants at Cricket and bash them with her bag…naturally, my vote goes to Cheryl…she looks even better without the ring!…
Alex wins for the outfit, except for that ridiculously huge bag. I don’t like anything about Cheryl’s outfit, but that woman is just almost unbelievably beautiful. Damn! And that hair….damn, again! LOL